Leaving My Cats Behind in NYC:
Why Cat Sitting Worked for Me
Published: September 7th, 2025
Hi, I’m Hannah, a cat mom living in downtown Manhattan. If you’ve ever searched for an NYC cat sitting service, you know how nerve-wracking it can feel to trust someone else with your cats.
I live with my boyfriend and two baby boys: Hughie, a playful all-grey kitten, and Teddy, my adult rescue tabby who has feline asthma. They’re deeply bonded to each other — and to us. Traveling with them is stressful, but leaving them behind without human affection is just as hard.
This is the story of how I found Feline Tails Cat Sitting, and why I now recommend them to any New York City cat owner looking for a reliable sitter.
What I Experienced With Other Pet Sitting Services
Before finding Feline Tails, I had tried a few other pet sitters in New York City. While some were fine, I often ran into the same issues that left me uneasy:
Quick in-and-out visits — sitters would refill food and water but spend little to no time actually engaging with the cats.
Missed details — special needs like medication or feeding schedules weren’t always followed precisely.
Limited updates — sometimes I’d get a short text, but rarely photos or thorough reports.
Unclear policies — not every service carried insurance or clearly outlined safety procedures, which made me nervous about handing over my keys and trusting them with my cats.
These small issues added up, leaving me worried and questioning whether my cats were truly cared for while I was away.
The Decision to Try Feline Tails
After looking into several cat sitters in NYC, Feline Tails stood out immediately. Not only do they specialize exclusively in cats, but every sitter goes through a rigorous manual background check — something that gave us real peace of mind. We were thoughtfully matched with our sitter, Meggy, based on our preferences, and from the start she went beyond the basics. She promised not just to feed and check in, but to truly spend time with the boys, keep their routines intact, and give them the affection they thrive on.
For two cats who live for love and consistency, that was more important than anything. And because Teddy also needed his inhaler, it mattered that we had someone experienced in cat care and trained to administer medication safely. Knowing Meggy could handle both their daily needs and Teddy’s health made us feel confident we’d found the perfect fit.
Why Feline Tails Was Different
From the very first interaction, Feline Tails Cat Sitting felt different. Here’s why:
Truly cat-focused — this isn’t a general pet sitting service; their sitters specialize in feline behavior and care.
Insured and professional — knowing they were a fully insured NYC cat sitting service gave me peace of mind.
Safety-first approach — clear policies around key handling, home security, and cat safety.
Companionship guaranteed — instead of rushing through visits, Meggy committed to giving Hughie and Teddy the affection, play, and routine they needed.
Daily, detailed updates — complete with photos and notes that made me feel like I was right there with them.
This level of professionalism and care was something I hadn’t experienced with other sitters — and it made all the difference.
The Result: Calm, Happy Cats
When we came home, I immediately saw the difference. Our cats weren’t frantic, stressed, or aloof. Instead, they were calm, affectionate, and clearly content.
Hughie, the kitten, hadn’t spiraled into hyperactive chaos, and Teddy wasn’t hiding or sulking. They had clearly gotten exactly what they needed: structure, companionship, and love.
For me, that was the true proof of a great cat sitting experience.
Why I’d Recommend Feline Tails
Hiring a cat sitter in New York is an act of trust. There are many services out there, but not all of them understand the emotional needs of cats.
My real-life experience with Feline Tails Cat Sitting proved that they go above and beyond. They respected my cats’ quirks, followed their routines perfectly, and gave me the reassurance I needed while I was away.
If you’re ever in the same position — torn about how to keep your cats comfortable while you travel — I can’t recommend Feline Tails enough. This isn’t just a cat sitting service; it’s peace of mind for both cats and cat parents.
📌 Feline Tails Purrks
✔️ Special offer: Use code HELLO15 for 50% off your first booking fee.
✔️ Senior discounts available — inquire if you’re 65+.
✔️ Cat-only focus — we’re not a generic pet sitting company; we’re cat-obsessed and cat-specialized.
✔️ Insured and professional — peace of mind knowing your sitter and your home are protected.
✔️ Personalized care — tailored routines for kittens, adults, bonded pairs, and special-needs cats.
✔️ Medication expertise — from asthma inhalers to supplements, sitters are trained to safely administer meds.
✔️ Companionship guaranteed — visits are never just food and litter; we spend quality time giving your cat love and enrichment.
✔️ Daily updates with photos — so you feel connected and reassured while you’re away.
✔️ Trusted by NYC cat parents — real reviews, real peace of mind.
✔️ Local and reliable — a small, New York–based team who truly understand the lives of city cats.
Reviewed by Hannah P. (29) – NYC Resident